Posted by: rbbadger | July 11, 2010

Dr Peter Breggin on the Fort Hood Shooter

Dr. Peter Breggin, MD is a bit of an unusual psychiatrist in that he is critical of the drugs which psychiatrists routinely prescribe.  I must state from the outset that I am not a fan of the mental health professions.  I have had fairly negative experiences with them.  While I do not doubt that there are well-meaning people in the professions, I am alarmed at the high rates at which doctors medicate their patients.  As a teacher, I have at least three students who, were they in a school in North America, would likely be on Ritalin or some other medication.  Here, they are not. 

Dr. Breggin is not surprised that the Fort Hood shooter was a psychiatrist.  According to him, many psychiatrists today are no longer interested in talking with their patients and doing psychotherapy in the traditional manner.  Rather, they are more interested in medicating their patients. 

“Modern psychiatry is not about counseling and empowering people. It’s about controlling and suppressing them, and that’s a dismal affair for patients and doctors alike. The armed forces have been taken in by the false claims of modern psychiatry.

“By contrast, it’s not depressing to do psychotherapy or counseling. As therapists, it’s inspiring when people entrust their feelings and their life stories to us. There is no burn out when therapists feel concern and empathy for their patients and help them to find the strength and direction to reclaim their lives.

“But being an ordinary psychiatrist is deadly depressing. Psychiatrists routinely commit spiritual murder by disregarding and suppressing their patients’ feelings and even their cognitive functions, making it impossible for them to conquer to their emotional struggles. It’s no wonder my colleagues have such high suicide and drug addiction rates.”

Dr. Breggin is basically critiquing how psychiatry is practiced in the US Armed Forces today.  You can read the rest of it here.

As an addendum, you might enjoy his piece on the dangers of psychiatric diagnosis.

Advertisements

Responses

  1. Modern psychology / psychiatry can cause more harms than benefits. And there are a lot of distortion and mockery against Christian values too. Once I felt offended by a psychiatry professor whose class material presented rosary as a psychopathological repetition of words. Homosexuality is now considered as a normal sexual orientation in psychiatry.

    BTW, according to Fr. Ripperger, FSSP, Many cases of multiple personalities and schizophrenia are actually demonic possessions and need exorcism by priests along with psychotherapy. Fr. Ripperger is an expert in the field of exorcism and psychology based on Thomas Aquinas. The audio files of his lecture can be found at http://www.sensustraditionis.org/multimedia.html

    Fr. Gabriele Amorth also wrote great books on exorcism, which I read with great interest. I think psychiatrists, at least serious Catholic psychiatrists, should consider exorcism, which should involve exorcist priests designated by bishops as a formal part of psychiatric treatment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: